His Golden Eyes :: Preface: Breaking Dawn Theory??

edwardlovesme · Posted: Wed Jul 16, 2008 9:15 pm

okay you guys... i think the battle between winning over bella ended in eclipse, seriously i thinks steph made it clear about bella's choices and etc.. and jacob would NEVER do that to bella no matter what.. because that would NOT make him better than edward right? and the whole time he was trying to convince bella not to let edward "end" her life; then what would be the point of him trying to kill her? because i think he would rather see her dead and happy with edward, then killing her, ending her life, and having a bunch of vampires trying to kill him.
it just doesnt seem very sensible or logical.

bella chose love in eclipse and the battle with jacob ended.
and whats wrong if jacob imprints and has a happy ending? why would stephenie ever want to end the book on a bad note fore someone?
i mean sure they'll be some struggle but in the end, everything will be fine.
i know it. no worries.

_________________

Rosalie_Hale · Posted: Wed Jul 16, 2008 9:45 pm

I just wanted to make a clarification on my theory. I DON'T think there will be an Edward-Bella-Jacob love triangle in BD. I agree with several others that this was put to rest in Eclipse. However, just because there is no love triangle, doesn't mean that Jacob is going to be out of the book. I don't think his part will necessarily be the biggest plot point, but I still think he will be involved. And again, this was my initial thought on the preface. Since I haven't come up with anything better, I'll stick with this until I read the book.

AndySweet · Posted: Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:24 pm

Oh Crap Oh Crap, It's not Jacob, it's EDWARD why the dream she keeps having about the Wolf Jacob protecting her and Mike yelling for her to run.
Remenber she said beloved, Oh Holy Crow, now why would Edward hurt Bella?

_________________

con by Shinyvolvo247 and banner to Blondegirl

Rosalie_Hale · Posted: Thu Jul 17, 2008 3:06 am

AndySweet wrote:

Oh Crap Oh Crap, It's not Jacob, it's EDWARD why the dream she keeps having about the Wolf Jacob protecting her and Mike yelling for her to run.
Remenber she said beloved, Oh Holy Crow, now why would Edward hurt Bella?

Umm....*looks both directions dumbfounded*...what?

Quickening · Posted: Thu Jul 17, 2008 5:14 am

The dream in the first book that Bella has right after she finds out that Edward is a vampire.

I think it would be nice if that was forshadowing what happens in the last book, but I doubt it. Stephenie Myer has said in many interviews that when she wrote that scene, she didn't even know that werewolves really existed in her universe, let alone that Jacob was one. I doubt she was setting up that Edward was going to try to kill Bella eventually.

I doubt Edward could at this point. After what he went through when he thought Bella was dead...

AndySweet · Posted: Thu Jul 17, 2008 11:55 am

Well I thought it was a theory I know Edward wouldn't hurt Bella willing but the keyword is beloved and Jacob is not that to her.

_________________

con by Shinyvolvo247 and banner to Blondegirl

xcullengrlx · Posted: Thu Jul 17, 2008 6:11 pm

commonsense101 wrote:

I was thinking. After reading the preface, which I know a lot
of people haven't and I am sorry. But reading it the first time
I was sure she was talking about Edward but then it didn't make
sense, she WANTS to give Edward her life, she has from the

beginning. She isn't afraid.
But her words in the preface sound like she has no choice, that
she is giving up. She seems afraid to me. Maybe.. know someone
said this on here before, but no one really paid attetnion, and it made perfect sense.

There is no way Jacob is going to galop into the sunset with a new beloved. No, that would be just to easy for all of them. I have a
feeling that his disgust towards her becoming a vamp, its going
to take over. He's going to try and kill Bella, to save her from eternal damnation. Remember he'd rather see her dead than become a bloodsucker.

I think it makes perfect sense. After the Eclipse, dawn breaks
and Jacob has a revelation, bella finally realizes that she does
want to marry Edward and its perfect, and then in the midst of
their happiness Jacob is back, luring Bella away on the night she is supposed to be changed by Edward and plans to kill her if he
cannot change her mind. Edward comes to the rescue, and
finds himself facing the end of his existence somehow. Bella tries to sacrafice herself for Edward like the third wife.....

I dont know sorry. its been playing in my head all day just like a movie.

thats a good theory. A thought crossed my mind that jacob would have a huge part of the whole wedding/bella changing bit. He's not going to sit back and let all that happen to the girl he loves. Im trying to stay positive, and think that even if something goes wrong then in the end it will turn out okay. But i really don't think he would kill her intetionaly. Ughh everytime i reply to a theory i get new ideas in my head. ughhh. I need to read the preface again.

_________________

"I don’t know if life is greater than death, but love was more than either."

Twilighter4Life · Posted: Thu Jul 17, 2008 6:38 pm

This is wat i think the preface is saying:

"Beloved" means Edward
and this is right before he is changing her into a vampire.
Because when ur a vampire ur practically dead right?
So if he does change then he's killing her.
So when Bella says that whole thing about it's hard to run away when the person that you love is killing you that probably means that Edward is about to change her and she is scared for some reason.
That's my theory

_________________

edwardlovesme · Posted: Thu Jul 17, 2008 8:50 pm

i think maybe right before he was going to change her, she REALLY realized what she was giving up, and she was having cold feet?

and why wouldnt she be scared? i mean shes been worried that she wont be the same afterwards for like, ever. And now she's givng up her humanity for the love of her existance, shes just afraid of being a newborn, not of edward. i think.

_________________

AndySweet · Posted: Thu Jul 17, 2008 11:05 pm

^
Thank you, I'm sick and tired of the people bringing up the stupid love triangle that according to Stephenie ended in Eclipse, so why are they bringing up again? seens when did this show turn into the Jacob Black Show? everything most revolve around him? hmm I thought it was Edward and Bella?

Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse, were tests that Bella and Edward had to go throw, challenges, they defeated each and everyone now comes one more.

Oh My God, I think some of us have figured it out while some are still stuck in the CW version with Bella, Jacob and Edward.

There is also a saying there is not a worse blind person that does not want to see

and a deaf person that does not listen.

_________________

con by Shinyvolvo247 and banner to Blondegirl

Quickening · Posted: Fri Jul 18, 2008 8:37 am

I think Edward is the beloved in the preface. I don't know what kind of situation would cause Edward to be trying to kill Bella though. Maybe it has to do with Alec's mysterious power? Stephenie did say that we should find out what it is in this book.

AndySweet · Posted: Fri Jul 18, 2008 1:43 pm

yes people 'beloved" that's the key word right there.

_________________

con by Shinyvolvo247 and banner to Blondegirl

AndySweet · Posted: Fri Jul 18, 2008 1:45 pm

yes people 'beloved" that's the key word right there.

_________________

con by Shinyvolvo247 and banner to Blondegirl

Rosalie_Hale · Posted: Tue Jul 22, 2008 11:06 pm

AndySweet wrote:

^
Thank you, I'm sick and tired of the people bringing up the stupid love triangle that according to Stephenie ended in Eclipse, so why are they bringing up again? seens when did this show turn into the Jacob Black Show? everything most revolve around him? hmm I thought it was Edward and Bella?

Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse, were tests that Bella and Edward had to go throw, challenges, they defeated each and everyone now comes one more.

Oh My God, I think some of us have figured it out while some are still stuck in the CW version with Bella, Jacob and Edward.

There is also a saying there is not a worse blind person that does not want to see

and a deaf person that does not listen.

I completely agree. Stephenie has said that Bella has already made her decision on the Edward vs. Jacob AND the stay human vs. become vampire issues in Eclipse. Soooo...Bella chooses Edward and to become a vampire. I'm not saying nothing will happen to make this difficult in Breaking Dawn, but the difficulty won't come from Bella. Even Bella states in Twilight that once she makes a decision, it's final. It's the process of making the decision that's difficult, but once it's made, she's committed.

AndySweet · Posted: Thu Jul 24, 2008 11:20 pm

But Jacob isn't her "beloved" and also Jacob throw in the towel as well.

_________________

con by Shinyvolvo247 and banner to Blondegirl